• E-mail
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
Member Login

Scottish Mediation

Engaging positively with conflict

Call our Helpline: 0131 556 8118

  • Home
  • Why mediation?
    • What is Mediation?
    • Mediation in the Third Sector
    • Types of mediation
      • Business and Commercial
      • Community and Neighbour
      • Education
      • Equalities
      • Family
      • Family Separation and Divorce
      • Housing and Property
      • Planning and environment
      • Workplace and Employment
      • Other
    • Scottish Mediation Charter
  • Find a mediator
  • About
    • Staff
    • Board
    • Board Committees
  • Join
    • Become a member
    • Register as a mediator
  • News
    • Blog
  • Events
  • Resources
    • General
    • For members
    • For schools
  • Young Talk | Peer Mediation
    • Who are we?
    • What do we provide?
    • Who can join?
    • Peer Mediation
    • Contacts
    • Events
    • Resources
    • Young Talk Telegraph
  • Contact us

Click here for Covid-19 Mediation Service information

Less Taxing with Mediation

5th November 2020

Taxation webinar aimed at easing disputes was well worth a lockdown look.

If you’d asked me to guess what sort of webinars I might be looking at during the Covid situation, I don’t think that one from the Chartered Institute of Taxation would have featured on my list. It’s not that Taxation isn’t important, it’s just not something that had been on my radar. I was alerted to just such a webinar being held by the CIT branch by the Chair of our board and, once I saw it had a mediation angle, I thought “let’s have a look”.

My previous experience of taxation disputes had been one in an earlier life where we had had a dispute over the level of VAT we were paying. In that case it ended up being contested and took a few years to sort out. That involved having to put aside money in case we lost, paying fees to our accountants and specialist tax advisers to take us through the process and a whole heap of management time devoted to making sure we had discussed things thoroughly and got together all the information that was required.

The webinar discussion was led by VAT specialist Veronica Donnelly from AZETS and I was both surprised and pleased to hear that Her Majesties Revenue and Customs (HMRC) have had a mediation scheme running for a few years now. HMRC have adapted the scheme over the past few years and made it more accessible this year.

Essentially the scheme is about allowing the taxpayer and HMRC to get together to solve a common problem. That may sound very straight forward but without setting up such a scheme it is often difficult for those sorts of conversations to take place and, in the absence of them disputes tend to just fester and grow.

In essence, taxpayers can apply for Alternative Dispute Resolution (which will usually be mediation) at any stage and don’t have to wait until they get to a tribunal before doing so. ADR can be considered where communications have broken down, where the facts are disputed, where the dispute is a result of a misunderstanding, where you want to know why HMRC have not agreed to the evidence you want to use, where you’re not clear on the information HMRC has used and where there is a need for further explanation.

After applying for ADR an HMRC facilitator will be in contact to discuss the case and consider whether ADR is appropriate. This is usually done by video conference. The process is like ‘normal’ mediation but with a few differences. The principal one is that if, in the course of discussion, you admit to a tax liability this can be taken forward and doesn’t stay inside the normally confidential confines of the mediation. Confidentiality however applies to all other aspects of the discussions and what is said inside the ADR process cannot be used “against you” should the case eventually go to tribunal.

The good news, as Veronica described it, is that the system works and that it has some great benefits. It can provide an opportunity for small business who aren’t interested in being a test case to get their case resolved quickly; equally where HMRC decide, after a conversation, to change their view, they can do so gracefully without setting a precedent in the glare of the formal VAT tribunal.
The process does, of course, need parties on both sides to be prepared to participate in the dialogue. Like any other mediation it also needs to have the decision makers “in the room”. If you’ve not been involved in how the conversation has led to a certain point it can be difficult sometimes to agree with the result.

Reflecting on the seminar I did a little more research and found that HMRC’s scheme had won an award for Innovation at this year’s National Mediation Awards. What to me made it a winner was that that HMRC have applied mediating ways to produce a mediation scheme that works for the disputes they deal with. It’s an approach that I hope will lead to similar ideas in different areas and sectors across Scotland and, as you might expect, Scottish Mediation are ready and willing to help other organisations to make such ideas a reality.

Email this to someoneShare on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Filed Under: Blog, News, News and Blog

Join Scottish Mediation

Membership of Scottish Mediation gives you access to a range of benefits and the opportunity to contribute to the future of mediation in Scotland.
  • Opportunities to Share and Learn
  • Free and Discounted Events
  • Exclusive Networking
  • Member resources
Join today

More news

The Time is Now

19th February 2021

Young People, Covid and the Importance of Positive Conversations

28th January 2021

Family Mediation Guest Blog – Rosanne Cubitt

22nd January 2021

Archives

Scottish Mediation Charter

Contact Scottish Mediation

Helpline: 0131 556 8118

18 York Place
Edinburgh
EH1 3EP

T: 0131 556 1221

E: admin@scottishmediation.org.uk

On Twitter @ScotMediation

  • Why not check out our 'Peer Mediation - Adult Skills Training' session for those interested in delivering peer medi… https://t.co/w8FfF2vkBV 24th February 2021 2:45 pm
  • Businesses want to direct their energies towards recovery from Covid and growing their enterprises. Mediation can t… https://t.co/Chq71wjxmW 19th February 2021 2:45 pm
  • It’s time to upscale mediation in schools. Positive impacts to self-esteem, contribution at school and maintaining… https://t.co/cOz5dnLY4S 19th February 2021 2:40 pm
  • It’s time to upscale mediation in schools. Positive impacts to self-esteem, contribution at school and maintaining… https://t.co/KgVENsr0iK 19th February 2021 2:38 pm
  • Climate change will have massive impacts across Scotland. Mediation can help to provide locally created solutions.… https://t.co/ZBlRHGfWR7 19th February 2021 2:35 pm
  • The use of mediation could increase access to justice and relieve some of the pressure on the courts whilst enablin… https://t.co/s8fbqRsCP9 18th February 2021 2:53 pm
  • Follow us

Sign up for our newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Privacy
  • Accessibility
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Sitemap

Copyright © 2021 Scottish Mediation · 18 York Place, Edinburgh, EH1 3EP · admin@scottishmediation.org.uk · T: 0131 556 1221
Scottish Charity Number SC034921 · Company Registered in Scotland SC258173
Site built by graphics.coop · Powered by WordPress